Discuss what you consider the most important dos and don’ts when giving peer feedback. What will make your peers' feedback most valuable to you?

  I have not much experience before about receiving the peer feedback from other people, I learned STA304 from last semester which used peerScholar to giving peer feedback to other students couple times. I think that when you come up with a full feedback, you should: First, briefly outline what you have read and what you think the other person has expressed, and praise the other person's strengths appropriately, such as some clever thinking. Pay attention to language logic. Secondly, when asking the other's problem, give a solution that you think is better. I don’t think that simply raising the mistake is a good idea. I think you can raise grammatical and logical questions. But you can't say that what the other person said is wrong. Different people have different opinions. We have no responsibility to deny others' opinions. I think giving peer feedback is a very good idea to comment and give opinions to each other, on the one hand to help each other to correct, on the other hand to help oneself learn the advantages of others and be careful not to make each other's mistakes. From STA304, I receive more than 3 different people’ feedback for my final project outline, which gave me a huge help on improve my work. They mentioned to use different knowledge points from class which I never think about it and a few grammar mistakes. This makes my project getting clearer and details. I think the feedback most valuable to me is to let me see the problem from a different perspective. Therefore, I think that a good feedback should be just right as an advice, read carefully and follow the person’s opinion. And it really help us to improve ourselves.